Sticky: Rilis Produk Susu Tercemar Bakteri Sakazakii

[aliasing]

Setelah IPB dan BPPOM tidak bersedia membeberkan nama produk susu yang telah / pernah tercemar bakteri enterobakter sakazakii, ada baiknya kita bisa mengetahui produk susu bayi apa saja di dunia ini yang pernah ditarik karena kasus serupa / hampir sama.

data ini diambil dari :
http://www.ibfan.org/site2005/abm/pa...h_art/85-6.xls
www.naba-breastfeeding.org/images/Recalls.pdf

data ada di attachment juga

================================================== ===
PRODUCT RECALL LIST (from 2000 to 2006)
No Date Country Company Brand Problem

1 8-Feb-06 Egypt Lacto-Misr Babysan 1 "Lacto-Misr was stopped from production after incidences of diarrhoea and GIT, believed to be cuased by an oil added to the formula. An investigation is still underway."

1 20-Dec-05 The Netherlands Nutricia Ovalrit & Beberix "(Refer problem under 2 below) 2 sterilizers in Nutricia factory in Opole, Poland, had defects, and glass particles lodged under the rim of the jar cover. VWA (Netherlands Health and Safety Authority) alerted the International Rapid Alert System. All Ovalrit and Beberix batches from the 2 defective sterilizers were recalled."

2 15-Dec-05 The Netherlands Nutricia Ovalrit 'tuingroenten met rijst' (garden vegetables with rice) Consumer complaint about tiny glass splinters under the rim of the cover. Nutricia withdrew the complete batch of Olvarit garden vegetables with rice with a best before date of 03 Aug 2008. Advert in nation-wide newspapers asks consumers to throw the pots in the dustbin. Costs of the jar will be reimbursed if cover is sent to Nutricia.

4 28-Nov-05 "France, Greece, La Reunion" "Numico/Milupa
Nestle" "Aptamil 2 Liquid, Aptamil Soya and Aptamil Babymil.
Nidal 2" (Refer to contamination by IsopropilThioXanthone below)

5 25-Nov-05 Italy "Numico/Milupa" "Aptamil 2 Liquid, Aptamil Soya and Aptamil Babymil: recalled products estimated to amount to less than 100,000 litres" "(Refer to contamination by IsopropilThioXanthone below) Milupa recalled about 100,000 litres of products. "

8 16-Oct-05 "Luxembourg, Netherlands " Babymill Cereabib 1 & 2 Contaminated with Enterobacter sakazakii. Recall after test by Le Laboratoire National de la sante - service du controle des denrees alimentaires.

10 "(28 Aug 05 - 3 Sep 05)" Hungary Milco "Feeding bottles of different capacity with teat ""Milco"" (type/model: a. 10099 bar code 4 711146 100992, b. 10095 bar code 4 711146 100947) capacity: 1.25ml; 2.14ml. Country of origin: unknown." "Chemical risk. The teat containts more DEHP and DINP phthalates than allowed. There is no consumer information, instructions of safe use and care attached to the product. Prohibition of distribution ordered by the authorities."

12 25-Jul-05 Argentina Mead Johnson Enfamil AR "Infant formula contaminated with Enterobacter sakazakii. All products recalled from shelf in the market, stocks blocked at importers and those already purchased by mothers to be recollected. Sale suspension ordered by the Federal Capital government."

19 11-Apr-05 "France exported to Middle East and Africa" Danone "Bledilait 2 eme age Gallia 2eme ageNursie 2eme age Alma 2eme age
Gallia 2eme age" "Salmonella agona caused illness in as many as 54 infants (1 to 12 months) from different parts of France between January and April 2005. Recalls were issued by the European Commission, Health and Consumer Protection Directorate. Authorities traced Salmonella to factory source. The Picot manufacturing facilities (see recall 10) were used to produce Danone products for export: Nursie, Alma, Gallia and Bledilait, hence the recall of these products as well. "

20 18-Feb-05 Finland Nutricia "Valio (Peptide Tutteli & Gefilus
Peptide Tutteli)" 10 times overdose of Vitamin D.

21 2-Feb-05 USA Abbott Ross "Similac Advance (with Iron)12.9 ounce cans" presence of black plastic particles.

22 Jan&Feb 2005 France Picot Picot "The Institut Pasteur in France identified an unusual number of strains of Salmonella serotype agona in Picot products. 44 children were affected, all aged between 1 to 6 months, hospitalised, all cured."

23 25-Jan-05 "Switzerland, France" Nestle liquid ready to feed Guigoz milks "The liquid milks looked abnormal (curdled) or had
unpleasant smell due to tiny leaks in the packaging."

24 25-Jan-05 "Sao Paulo, Brazil" "Numico/Milupa
distributor: ProdutosNutricionais Ltda " Aptamil infant formula "Product batch banned due to detection of EnterobacterSakazakii bacteria. Imposition of temporary ban of 6months on product."

25 1-Jan-05 "Sao Paulo, Brazil" Mead Johnson "Pregestimil, Enfamil Pregestimil" "ANVISA (Brazilian Food Control Agency) banned the use, marketing, distribution and entry into Brazil of these infant formulas. (Ministry of Health of France is investigating the relationship of these products with a type of bacterial infection.)"

26 1-Dec-04 USA Mead Johnson Enfamil LactoFree with Lipil "Mead Johnson brand Enfamil LactoFree with LIPIL milk-based infant formula, lactose-free, iron fortified, concentrated liquid in a 13 fl. oz. can. Sold in cases of 12 cans each; case UPC 3-0087-0614-01. 6408 cases in total. May have an off-odor, clumping and product separation. Bristol Myers Squibb Company, Evansville, IN, by letter dated December 9, 2003. "

27 12-Oct-04 "France, Hong Kong,UK, Brazil, The Gambia, Gabon, UK and others" Mead Johnson Pregestimil Infant formula contaminated with Enterobacter Sakazakii. 2 out of 4 infants died. 3 of them consumed Pregestimil and the 4th had direct contact with one of the ill ****es.

28 7-Sep-04 "New York, USA" Guan Wei Yuan Guan Wei Yuan "Products do not contain amounts of protein and other essential ingredients as indicated on the label. On-going and exclusive consumption of these formulas could have severe health consequences, particularly in newborn infants, pre-mature infants or others with weakened immune systems."

29 6-Sep-04 Australia Nestle NAN 1 Probiotic Starter infant formula with Bifidus "Incorrect mix of formulation, not meeting the Food Standards regulation. Possible changes in the protein and iron levels, leading to constipation and/or diarrhoea."

31 31-Mar-04 "Ottawa, Ontario, USA" Mead Johnson Enfalac Pregestimil Hypoallergenic Infant formula. "Incorrect size of scoop, results in over-concentrated formula preparation, with severe medical problems such as diarrhoea and dehydration."

32 11-Oct-03 Israel "Humana (Germany); Remedia, Israel" "Tzimchit Super Formula - soya-based milk substitute
Junior Tzimchit Super Formula" "Lack of vitamin B1 or thiamine, all ****es hospitalised had been fed with Remedia. 2 infant deaths since June, 3 in critical condition in hospital, 10 suspicious case
under investigation. Health Ministry said 7 infants fed with formula suffered beriberi. "

33 1-Sep-03 "Evansville, Ind, USA" Mead Johnson Enfacare LIPIL Infant Formula Voluntary recall 505 cases of EnfaCare LIPIL 12.9 ounce. Contaminated with Enterobacter Sakazakii.

34 1-Nov-02 China "Wyeth (Shanghai
Wyeth Nutritional Co. Ltd.)" "Nursoy, Promise" Promise milk powder had nitrate content exceeding the national standard. Nursoy contained Enterobacter sakazakii. Recall of over 100 million tins of milk formula.

35 11-Feb-02 USA Wyeth "Baby Basics, Kozy Kids, CVS, Hill Country Fare, HEB Baby, American Fare Little Ones, Home Best, Safeway Select, Healthy Baby, Walgreens, Parent's Choice " FDA testing at the Wyeth plant found contamination by Enterobacter sakazakii.

36 5-Feb-02 Belgium Nestle Beba 1 "5 day old infant died due to Enterobacter Sakazakii after discharge from hospital. On 2nd May, nearly seven weeks after the infant died, the Federal Agency for Food Safety in Belgium asked Nestlé Belgium to recall Beba 1."

37 Y2002 USA Mead Johnson Portagen Portagen is a special formula used for infants with difficulty digesting fats. The recall was prompted by the death of a premature infant in April 2001 from meningitis caused by Portagen contaminated with Enterobacter sakazakii.

38 14-Sep-01 "Texas, USA" Nestle "Nestle Carnation Follow-Up Formula, 32-Fluid-Ounce Liquid ready to Feed" 120 cans distributed only to WalMart stores in Texas cities. Excessive magnesium in cans. Long term use may cause severe adverse health effects such as low blood pressure and irregular heart beat.

39 15-Aug-01 UK Wyeth "SMA GoldSMA White" Infant botulism. A 5-month-old girl became seriously ill.

40 7-Jul-01 USA Mead Johnson Nutramigen "Spanish label errors - incorrect preparation instructions. Incorrect amount of water alters formula's precise mixture of nutrients and could cause seizures,
irregular heartbeat and even death if consumed for several days. "

41 Yr 2000 USA "Abbott RossMead Johnson" "Isomil powder and concentrate; Similac with iron, low iron powder and concentrate; Neosure powder; Enfamil low iron and with iron powder, Enfamil Lacto-free powder;
Prosobee soy powder; Nutramigen powder" "Infant formulas were packaged in cardboard tray/boxes which were misbranded. All lots of cardboard cases and trays that were repackaged, labeled and distributed by Unity Wholesale Grocery since April 25, 2000."

43 18-Mar-00 USA Nestle "Nestle Carnation Good Start
Nestle Carnation AlsoyNestle Carnation Follow-Up" "Not properly sterilized, voluntary recall for precautionary measures. Concern that formula may not have reached a high enough temperature during sterilisation."

[sXupid]

serem amat susu ada bakteri..

[Jarosit]

mas/mbak... tau metode sampling dan metode identifikasi bakterinya tidak?

waktu ada acara dialog apa kabar indonesia di tv-one hari... kamis (28/2/08) yang ngundang ibu-ibu peneliti dari IPB dan Ibu dai BPOM, belaiau-beliau itu tidak membahas metode penentuan/identifikasi bakteri ntu... padahal itu yang paling penting.

Btw IPB kok hobi ya bikin penelitian kontroversial.. iklan AirCon LG yang katanya bisa membunuh virus flu burung itu kan juga atas rekomendasi dari hasil penelitian IPB...

[aliasing]

terlepas apa metode samplingnya, bakteri enterobacter sakazakii ternyata memang bisa terkontaminasi ke susu formula. dan ini sudah pernah dibuktikan serta dikeluarkannya kebijakan penarikan susu formula di banyak negara.

coba lihat posting saya diatas.

karena tidak ada yang mau memberitahukan nama produknya, ya kita harus hati2. setidaknya kita bisa tahu merek2 pabrikan mana saja yang pernah mengalaminya di negara lain.

[aliasing]

Originally Posted by Jarosit

mas/mbak... tau metode sampling dan metode identifikasi bakterinya tidak?

waktu ada acara dialog apa kabar indonesia di tv-one hari... kamis (28/2/08) yang ngundang ibu-ibu peneliti dari IPB dan Ibu dai BPOM, belaiau-beliau itu tidak membahas metode penentuan/identifikasi bakteri ntu... padahal itu yang paling penting.

Btw IPB kok hobi ya bikin penelitian kontroversial.. iklan AirCon LG yang katanya bisa membunuh virus flu burung itu kan juga atas rekomendasi dari hasil penelitian IPB...

terlepas apa metode samplingnya, bakteri enterobacter sakazakii ternyata memang bisa terkontaminasi ke susu formula. dan ini sudah pernah dibuktikan serta dikeluarkannya kebijakan penarikan susu formula di banyak negara.

coba lihat posting saya diatas.

karena tidak ada yang mau memberitahukan nama produknya, ya kita harus hati2. setidaknya kita bisa tahu merek2 pabrikan mana saja yang pernah mengalaminya di negara lain.
___________

[doel_I]

Originally Posted by aliasing

Setelah IPB dan BPPOM tidak bersedia membeberkan nama produk susu yang telah / pernah tercemar bakteri enterobakter sakazakii, ada baiknya kita bisa mengetahui produk susu bayi apa saja di dunia ini yang pernah ditarik karena kasus serupa / hampir sama.

data ini diambil dari :
http://www.ibfan.org/site2005/abm/pa...h_art/85-6.xls
www.naba-breastfeeding.org/images/Recalls.pdf

data ada di attachment juga

================================================== ===
PRODUCT RECALL LIST (from 2000 to 2006)
No Date Country Company Brand Problem

1 8-Feb-06 Egypt Lacto-Misr Babysan 1 "Lacto-Misr was stopped from production after incidences of diarrhoea and GIT, believed to be cuased by an oil added to the formula. An investigation is still underway."

1 20-Dec-05 The Netherlands Nutricia Ovalrit & Beberix "(Refer problem under 2 below) 2 sterilizers in Nutricia factory in Opole, Poland, had defects, and glass particles lodged under the rim of the jar cover. VWA (Netherlands Health and Safety Authority) alerted the International Rapid Alert System. All Ovalrit and Beberix batches from the 2 defective sterilizers were recalled."

2 15-Dec-05 The Netherlands Nutricia Ovalrit 'tuingroenten met rijst' (garden vegetables with rice) Consumer complaint about tiny glass splinters under the rim of the cover. Nutricia withdrew the complete batch of Olvarit garden vegetables with rice with a best before date of 03 Aug 2008. Advert in nation-wide newspapers asks consumers to throw the pots in the dustbin. Costs of the jar will be reimbursed if cover is sent to Nutricia.

4 28-Nov-05 "France, Greece, La Reunion" "Numico/Milupa
Nestle" "Aptamil 2 Liquid, Aptamil Soya and Aptamil Babymil.
Nidal 2" (Refer to contamination by IsopropilThioXanthone below)

5 25-Nov-05 Italy "Numico/Milupa" "Aptamil 2 Liquid, Aptamil Soya and Aptamil Babymil: recalled products estimated to amount to less than 100,000 litres" "(Refer to contamination by IsopropilThioXanthone below) Milupa recalled about 100,000 litres of products. "

8 16-Oct-05 "Luxembourg, Netherlands " Babymill Cereabib 1 & 2 Contaminated with Enterobacter sakazakii. Recall after test by Le Laboratoire National de la sante - service du controle des denrees alimentaires.

10 "(28 Aug 05 - 3 Sep 05)" Hungary Milco "Feeding bottles of different capacity with teat ""Milco"" (type/model: a. 10099 bar code 4 711146 100992, b. 10095 bar code 4 711146 100947) capacity: 1.25ml; 2.14ml. Country of origin: unknown." "Chemical risk. The teat containts more DEHP and DINP phthalates than allowed. There is no consumer information, instructions of safe use and care attached to the product. Prohibition of distribution ordered by the authorities."

12 25-Jul-05 Argentina Mead Johnson Enfamil AR "Infant formula contaminated with Enterobacter sakazakii. All products recalled from shelf in the market, stocks blocked at importers and those already purchased by mothers to be recollected. Sale suspension ordered by the Federal Capital government."

19 11-Apr-05 "France exported to Middle East and Africa" Danone "Bledilait 2 eme age Gallia 2eme ageNursie 2eme age Alma 2eme age
Gallia 2eme age" "Salmonella agona caused illness in as many as 54 infants (1 to 12 months) from different parts of France between January and April 2005. Recalls were issued by the European Commission, Health and Consumer Protection Directorate. Authorities traced Salmonella to factory source. The Picot manufacturing facilities (see recall 10) were used to produce Danone products for export: Nursie, Alma, Gallia and Bledilait, hence the recall of these products as well. "

20 18-Feb-05 Finland Nutricia "Valio (Peptide Tutteli & Gefilus
Peptide Tutteli)" 10 times overdose of Vitamin D.

21 2-Feb-05 USA Abbott Ross "Similac Advance (with Iron)12.9 ounce cans" presence of black plastic particles.

22 Jan&Feb 2005 France Picot Picot "The Institut Pasteur in France identified an unusual number of strains of Salmonella serotype agona in Picot products. 44 children were affected, all aged between 1 to 6 months, hospitalised, all cured."

23 25-Jan-05 "Switzerland, France" Nestle liquid ready to feed Guigoz milks "The liquid milks looked abnormal (curdled) or had
unpleasant smell due to tiny leaks in the packaging."

24 25-Jan-05 "Sao Paulo, Brazil" "Numico/Milupa
distributor: ProdutosNutricionais Ltda " Aptamil infant formula "Product batch banned due to detection of EnterobacterSakazakii bacteria. Imposition of temporary ban of 6months on product."

25 1-Jan-05 "Sao Paulo, Brazil" Mead Johnson "Pregestimil, Enfamil Pregestimil" "ANVISA (Brazilian Food Control Agency) banned the use, marketing, distribution and entry into Brazil of these infant formulas. (Ministry of Health of France is investigating the relationship of these products with a type of bacterial infection.)"

26 1-Dec-04 USA Mead Johnson Enfamil LactoFree with Lipil "Mead Johnson brand Enfamil LactoFree with LIPIL milk-based infant formula, lactose-free, iron fortified, concentrated liquid in a 13 fl. oz. can. Sold in cases of 12 cans each; case UPC 3-0087-0614-01. 6408 cases in total. May have an off-odor, clumping and product separation. Bristol Myers Squibb Company, Evansville, IN, by letter dated December 9, 2003. "

27 12-Oct-04 "France, Hong Kong,UK, Brazil, The Gambia, Gabon, UK and others" Mead Johnson Pregestimil Infant formula contaminated with Enterobacter Sakazakii. 2 out of 4 infants died. 3 of them consumed Pregestimil and the 4th had direct contact with one of the ill ****es.

28 7-Sep-04 "New York, USA" Guan Wei Yuan Guan Wei Yuan "Products do not contain amounts of protein and other essential ingredients as indicated on the label. On-going and exclusive consumption of these formulas could have severe health consequences, particularly in newborn infants, pre-mature infants or others with weakened immune systems."

29 6-Sep-04 Australia Nestle NAN 1 Probiotic Starter infant formula with Bifidus "Incorrect mix of formulation, not meeting the Food Standards regulation. Possible changes in the protein and iron levels, leading to constipation and/or diarrhoea."

31 31-Mar-04 "Ottawa, Ontario, USA" Mead Johnson Enfalac Pregestimil Hypoallergenic Infant formula. "Incorrect size of scoop, results in over-concentrated formula preparation, with severe medical problems such as diarrhoea and dehydration."

32 11-Oct-03 Israel "Humana (Germany); Remedia, Israel" "Tzimchit Super Formula - soya-based milk substitute
Junior Tzimchit Super Formula" "Lack of vitamin B1 or thiamine, all ****es hospitalised had been fed with Remedia. 2 infant deaths since June, 3 in critical condition in hospital, 10 suspicious case
under investigation. Health Ministry said 7 infants fed with formula suffered beriberi. "

33 1-Sep-03 "Evansville, Ind, USA" Mead Johnson Enfacare LIPIL Infant Formula Voluntary recall 505 cases of EnfaCare LIPIL 12.9 ounce. Contaminated with Enterobacter Sakazakii.

34 1-Nov-02 China "Wyeth (Shanghai
Wyeth Nutritional Co. Ltd.)" "Nursoy, Promise" Promise milk powder had nitrate content exceeding the national standard. Nursoy contained Enterobacter sakazakii. Recall of over 100 million tins of milk formula.

35 11-Feb-02 USA Wyeth "Baby Basics, Kozy Kids, CVS, Hill Country Fare, HEB Baby, American Fare Little Ones, Home Best, Safeway Select, Healthy Baby, Walgreens, Parent's Choice " FDA testing at the Wyeth plant found contamination by Enterobacter sakazakii.

36 5-Feb-02 Belgium Nestle Beba 1 "5 day old infant died due to Enterobacter Sakazakii after discharge from hospital. On 2nd May, nearly seven weeks after the infant died, the Federal Agency for Food Safety in Belgium asked Nestlé Belgium to recall Beba 1."

37 Y2002 USA Mead Johnson Portagen Portagen is a special formula used for infants with difficulty digesting fats. The recall was prompted by the death of a premature infant in April 2001 from meningitis caused by Portagen contaminated with Enterobacter sakazakii.

38 14-Sep-01 "Texas, USA" Nestle "Nestle Carnation Follow-Up Formula, 32-Fluid-Ounce Liquid ready to Feed" 120 cans distributed only to WalMart stores in Texas cities. Excessive magnesium in cans. Long term use may cause severe adverse health effects such as low blood pressure and irregular heart beat.

39 15-Aug-01 UK Wyeth "SMA GoldSMA White" Infant botulism. A 5-month-old girl became seriously ill.

40 7-Jul-01 USA Mead Johnson Nutramigen "Spanish label errors - incorrect preparation instructions. Incorrect amount of water alters formula's precise mixture of nutrients and could cause seizures,
irregular heartbeat and even death if consumed for several days. "

41 Yr 2000 USA "Abbott RossMead Johnson" "Isomil powder and concentrate; Similac with iron, low iron powder and concentrate; Neosure powder; Enfamil low iron and with iron powder, Enfamil Lacto-free powder;
Prosobee soy powder; Nutramigen powder" "Infant formulas were packaged in cardboard tray/boxes which were misbranded. All lots of cardboard cases and trays that were repackaged, labeled and distributed by Unity Wholesale Grocery since April 25, 2000."

43 18-Mar-00 USA Nestle "Nestle Carnation Good Start
Nestle Carnation AlsoyNestle Carnation Follow-Up" "Not properly sterilized, voluntary recall for precautionary measures. Concern that formula may not have reached a high enough temperature during sterilisation."

makasih atas infonya. klo kasus di indonesia ada infonya gak.

[cuma_liat]

Sebenarnya siaapa seh yg mau di proteksi ?
Kepentingan rakyat banyak atau kepentingan perusahaan/bisnis/pengusaha?

Kalau terang" ada terkontaminasi dan berbahaya untuk di konsumsi rakyat banyak, harus di beritakan dan si perusahaan juga harus menarik produk nya dan memberitakan di media massa.
Hal ini yg terjadi di LN, entah mengapa lain halnya di Indonesia.
Gimana YLKI ? apa tindakannya?

Makanya aku lebih suka kasih ASI ke bayi" ku dulu.....dan susu sapi murni setelah itu.

[cuma_liat]

Originally Posted by Jarosit

mas/mbak... tau metode sampling dan metode identifikasi bakterinya tidak?

waktu ada acara dialog apa kabar indonesia di tv-one hari... kamis (28/2/08) yang ngundang ibu-ibu peneliti dari IPB dan Ibu dai BPOM, belaiau-beliau itu tidak membahas metode penentuan/identifikasi bakteri ntu... padahal itu yang paling penting.

Btw IPB kok hobi ya bikin penelitian kontroversial.. iklan AirCon LG yang katanya bisa membunuh virus flu burung itu kan juga atas rekomendasi dari hasil penelitian IPB...

Air Con LG bisa membunuh virus flu burung? Hebat banget yach !!!
Apa ini nga cuma bisnis saja?
Klo memang bisa membunuh virus flu burung - pasti di negara" lain merekomendasikannya segera - karna riset untuk membuat antidot/vaccine cukup lama dan makan banyak uang.

[kapiten_de]

kembali konsumsi susu segar aja ahhh

[aliasing]

MOderatornya nggak nyambung . ini bukan topik LINGKUNGAN !!!!! tapi lebih ke politik karena POM dan IPB nggak mau mengumumkan !!!!!
nggak ada hubungannya sama lingkungan ini....

Main pindah - pindah aja.....; gak pakai konfirmasi ke TS!!!!
nggak sekalian pindahin ini thread ke GOSIP !!